
Police in Karnataka have registered a second criminal case against a Catholic priest accused of sexually abusing children. The development has prompted child rights campaigners and Catholic lay leaders to call for a wider investigation into how Church authorities handled the allegations.
Father Cyprian Pinto, 65, parish priest of St Vincent Ferrer Church in Valencia, Mangaluru, was arrested on 18 October over allegations that he sexually abused a 14-year-old boy who regularly visited a church to pray.
Police announced on 9 November that a further case had been registered against him under India’s Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act. The new complaint alleges that Pinto sexually assaulted a 13-year-old boy on 13 May, when he was serving at St Sebastian Church in Permannur village, near Olapete in Mangaluru.
Pinto was transferred to Valencia on 26 May after completing six years at the Permannur parish. Police said they had identified five alleged victims who were minors at the time of the incidents when the priest was first arrested.
Mangaluru Police Commissioner Sudheer Kumar Reddy told UCA News on 10 November that Pinto had been remanded in judicial custody until 30 October and was later released on bail. The court ordered him to cooperate with the investigation.
Roy Castelino, public relations officer for the Diocese of Mangalore, said Pinto had not been arrested in connection with the second case. He confirmed that the priest had been suspended from parish duties and was receiving medical treatment at home after his release. Castelino also said the diocese had sent a report about the allegations to the Vatican.
Child rights activist Stanly KV, who helped the family of the first alleged victim file a police complaint, said eight boys had raised allegations against Pinto with Bishop Peter Paul Saldanha in August. According to Stanly, five of them submitted individual letters describing the alleged abuse.
He accused the bishop of failing to report the allegations to police for two months and called for an investigation into the diocese’s response. Stanly, founding secretary of the organisation Odanadi Seva Samsthe, which works against human trafficking and sexual exploitation, also called for a special investigation team to examine whether complaints had been suppressed and whether Church officials knew about the alleged abuse.
Stanly said a further complaint had been made to the Mangaluru police commissioner by a 35-year-old Catholic man. The man reportedly alleged that Pinto had sexually assaulted him when he was a teenager and attended a church where Pinto was parish priest.
The activist also said he had approached the Karnataka High Court’s Juvenile Justice Committee over concerns that four other children who were prepared to make complaints were being pressured or intimidated into remaining silent.
Robert Rosario, a member of the Mangaluru Association of Concerned Catholics, said Pinto had served as a priest since 1988 under three bishops. Rosario alleged that Church leaders had known about the priest’s behaviour but had failed to act, allowing him to move between parishes. He called for Bishop Saldanha to be investigated over the handling of the complaints.
Some Catholic lay leaders, speaking anonymously, also expressed concern that certain priests had used Mass sermons to encourage parishioners to pray for Pinto and the bishop without giving sufficient attention to the alleged victims and their families.
The allegations have raised questions about safeguarding procedures and the responsibility of religious institutions to report suspected child abuse to the authorities. Under Indian law, the identities of children who have experienced sexual violence must be kept confidential.
Source: UCA News.