Indonesian Church Faces Opposition Despite Meeting Legal Requirements

(Photo: Unsplash/Nick Agus Arya)

A church in Indonesia has faced protests from hundreds of Muslims despite receiving the necessary recommendations and support to proceed with construction, according to local reports.

The dispute concerns a planned building for the Simalungun Protestant Christian Church (Gereja Kristen Protestan Simalungun, GKPS) on Cikopo Main Road in Cilodong, Purwakarta Regency, West Java Province.

Purwakarta Regent Saepul Bahri Binzein said the project had received recommendations from the local Religious Harmony Forum and the Ministry of Religious Affairs. He also pledged to ensure that the church’s documents and requirements were complete, affirming the right of Christians to worship.

The church had secured support from 125 local residents and 90 prospective members of the congregation, according to the Purwakarta Religious Harmony Forum (FKUB) and the local Ministry of Religious Affairs.

Despite this, members of the Forum for Safeguarding the Faith of the Islamic Community (Forum Penyelamat Akidah Umat Islam, FPAUI), joined by other residents of Cilodong village, staged a protest at the proposed construction site.

According to Tvberita.co.id, demonstrators gathered after Friday prayers at the Tajug Gede Mosque before marching towards the site. Wearing white clothing, they carried a banner reading, “Defend the Faith, Oppose Legal Violations”, while police monitored the demonstration.

Protesters argued that Muslims made up 99% of the area's population and objected to the church's proximity to the Al-Hidayah Mosque and an Islamic boarding school. They also alleged, without providing evidence in the reports, that poor Muslim residents had been paid to support the church project and that people wishing to speak about the alleged payments had faced intimidation.

In a video of the protest circulating online, one demonstrator speaking from a truck declared that Islam was the only religion accepted by Allah and rejected the legitimacy of other faiths. He also repeated the allegation that the church had paid local residents to support its construction.

The speaker claimed that each person had received an average of Rp5 million, approximately US$285, and alleged that some residents wanted to return the money but were afraid to come forward because of intimidation. These claims were not independently established in the reports.

Elyasa Budianto, a lawyer representing residents opposed to the project, said the dispute centred on a community consultation meeting held on 3 May. He claimed that 47 Muslim residents had opposed the construction, while 28 had supported it, Beritapembaruan.com reported.

“The outcome of the initial consultation meeting must be respected. Residents want certainty that there is no process that deceives the community,” Budianto said, according to Tvberita.co.id.

He said documents concerning the church's construction process had been submitted to the regent, along with other evidence. The opponents were seeking cancellation of the project, arguing that there had been objections during the local permitting process.

The latest demonstration followed an earlier protest on 8 October, when hundreds of members of the Purwakarta Community Alliance gathered outside the local government offices and the Ministry of Religious Affairs office. They called on officials to revoke the church's construction permit.

The FKUB's support for the project was also backed by the West Java office of the Ministry of Human Rights. The office said the church had received support from more than 90 prospective worshippers and 60 local residents. It urged both sides to resolve the disagreement through dialogue and respect for the law, Kompas.com reported.

During a meeting with GKPS congregation members on 11 October, Gugun Gumilar, a special staff member to Indonesia's Minister of Religious Affairs, said construction could go ahead. He said the requirements for establishing the place of worship had been met, based on the documents and information available to him.

Pastor Nicky Jefta Wakary, of the Tegar Beriman Church in the Cipta Graha Permai housing complex in Cibinong, Bogor Regency, said the government's response to religious intolerance often remained symbolic. His own church had previously encountered opposition from nearby Muslim residents.

“In several rulings, Indonesia’s Supreme Court has affirmed that licensing regulations are intended to create order and religious harmony, not to restrict freedom of belief,” Pastor Nicky told Morning Star News. “In practice, however, implementation often tells a different story. Intolerance keeps recurring because the authorities are not firm.”

Suspect Arrested Over Arson Attack on Pork-Noodle Restaurant

In a separate incident in Central Java Province, police arrested a suspect accused of helping plan an arson and vandalism attack on a pork-noodle restaurant in Sukoharjo.

The suspect, identified only as “I”, was arrested in Solo on 6 November. Central Java Regional Police believe he was the main organiser of the attack on the Mi Babi Tepi Sawah restaurant in Parangjoro village, Grogol District, Suara.com reported.

Sukoharjo Police Chief AKBP Indra Maulana Saputra said the suspect had recruited another man to take part in the attack on 12 September, according to Kompas.com.

Police allege that the suspect threatened a restaurant security guard with a sharp weapon while his accomplice, identified as A.S., damaged the premises, poured petrol over the building and set it alight.

A.S. had been arrested earlier, on 19 October, in Purbayan village, Baki District, Sukoharjo. He allegedly resisted arrest with a sharp weapon, injuring two members of the Central Java Mobile Brigade, Suara.com reported.

Police said the alleged perpetrators objected to the presence of a restaurant selling pork products in their neighbourhood. Pork is prohibited under Islamic dietary rules.

As part of the investigation, a joint team from the Central Java Regional Police, Sukoharjo Police and Karanganyar Police searched two Islamic boarding schools for girls on 27 October. The searches took place in Laban village, Mojolaban District, Sukoharjo, and Trengguli village, Jenawi District, Karanganyar.

Led by Central Java Police Chief Inspector General Roy Hardi Siahaan, officers recovered several items, including sharp weapons, bows and arrows, Solopos.com reported. Police said the evidence did not mean that all students at the schools were involved in criminal activity.

The searches drew criticism from several groups, including the local Indonesian Ulema Council. Critics accused police of going too far by entering religious institutions and frightening female students, some of whom reportedly did not have time to put on their hijabs.

Source credit: Morning Star News.